New Winch or Winch Strap?

cyclops222

Commander
Joined
Mar 21, 2024
Messages
2,470
Why can not 2 people back the boat in just far enough to get it on the boards or guides? Then back in the rest of the way ? I can do it alone. With a person in the vehicle and a driver in the boat. Both on cell phones. Done
 

airshot

Vice Admiral
Joined
Jul 22, 2008
Messages
5,616
All old people should have a electric winch. It will keep you young forever.
I considered that before buying my two speed winch. Then figured how much time it takes to crank less than 18" on the winch. I would be done cranking long before I had the battery connected on the electric winch. Now if I still had my Islander, there would be an electric winch on there !! My 16' side console comes in around 1200# tops....takes less than one minute to crank up that last 18" or less. I try to work smarter, rather than harder, especially at my age !!
 

aspeck

Moderator
Staff member
Joined
May 29, 2003
Messages
19,276
I have shortened my strap enough times that I am about to have to replace it. As the sun deteriorates the exposed portion, I cut off and re-fasten so I don't loose the boat when it is not convenient to do so. I bought my boat about 15 years ago (used at the time) and haven't yet replaced the strap ... continue to lube the winch and shorten the strap when it starts to fray. I feel that this might be the last year for the strap ...
 

airshot

Vice Admiral
Joined
Jul 22, 2008
Messages
5,616
I've thought about making mine work with my drill. Anyone ever done that?
Now that I have spent some time thinking about your idea, the better I like it.. Not sure how well it would work on a 1 speed winch where the cranking can be difficult, but with my two speed in low gear, I don't think it would be a problem. I can crank my 1200# boat on with just a finger like spinning an airplane propeller, so why wouldn't it work ? If I were cranking all 16' of boat onto the trailer, I would be doing my homework. As is, I only crank a little over a foot, so not worth the effort. In fact, as have been looking at one of those latches that catch your bow eye....the " boat2trailer" unit is the one I have been thinking about. I can power load at our ramps, and when done correctly, causes no damage to the ramp. Even our local DNR officer came over and congratulated me on doing it properly earlier this season when he came over for a boat inspection. Hmmmm...electric drill ??
 
Last edited:

airshot

Vice Admiral
Joined
Jul 22, 2008
Messages
5,616
Why can not 2 people back the boat in just far enough to get it on the boards or guides? Then back in the rest of the way ? I can do it alone. With a person in the vehicle and a driver in the boat. Both on cell phones. Done
It works when you have two people....I am usually alone...and even when I do have another person, I have been doing this for so long, that another person gets in the way ! If I still had my 22'....that would be another story.
 

Pmt133

Master Chief Petty Officer
Joined
Jan 6, 2022
Messages
847
Even the low speed on my winch brings some resistance lol. The couple of ramps that I do have to full length winch aren't that much of a work out but it's enough. The speed also isn't that bad. On the flip side the high speed setting is a bear and far worse than the single speed it replaced. You guys both probably are lighter than my 19 is though. So it may work. I know my corded drill can throw me around. My 20v stuff I've been able to locked rotor working without much effort. But a lighter boat may be fine thinking about it.

I went outside and double checked what I had on the boat. Its a dutton lainson 2500. A serious unit...
 

dingbat

Supreme Mariner
Joined
Nov 20, 2001
Messages
16,513
Do yourself a favor......back in and get your bunks wet prior to loading the boat..... your shoulder will thank you

68 yro.....no problem winching #5,200 the last foot or so to the stop with a Dutton DL2500A
 

airshot

Vice Admiral
Joined
Jul 22, 2008
Messages
5,616
Quality of winch makes a big difference, years back I had a trailer with a 2000# manual winch but an off brand cheap job, it did work fine, never an issue, so I thought. Friend found a brand new winch at a garage sale for cheap, also rated at 2000# capacity. What the hey.....new shiny winch vs old rusty looking winch....this was a no brainer. After mounting, I noticed the new winch had a longer crank and a much more comfortable handle. Wow..what a difference in the effort it took to crank the same boat on the same trailer...much easier ! Good winch can make a big difference !!
 

mike_i

Ensign
Joined
Jun 28, 2017
Messages
988
I've been doing the same thing for many years.
I have shortened my strap enough times that I am about to have to replace it. As the sun deteriorates the exposed portion, I cut off and re-fasten so I don't loose the boat when it is not convenient to do so. I bought my boat about 15 years ago (used at the time) and haven't yet replaced the strap ... continue to lube the winch and shorten the strap when it starts to fray. I feel that this might be the last year for the strap ...
 
Top